Motion summary The question was put that clause 12 be agreed to. The Committee divided: Votes by party/group Download results Download as text Download as CSV Download PNG version of graph List by party/group List by Member Individual votes by party/group Members voting Content Members voting Not Content Tellers for the Contents Newby, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Taylor of Holbeach, L. Conservative Life peer Members voting Content Conservative (137) Ahmad of Wimbledon, L. Conservative Life peer Anelay of St Johns, B. Conservative Life peer Ashcroft, L. Conservative Life peer Ashton of Hyde, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Astor of Hever, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Attlee, E. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Baker of Dorking, L. Conservative Life peer Balfe, L. Conservative Life peer Bates, L. Conservative Life peer Berridge, B. Conservative Life peer Blencathra, L. Conservative Life peer Borwick, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Bottomley of Nettlestone, B. Conservative Life peer Bourne of Aberystwyth, L. Conservative Life peer Bowness, L. Conservative Life peer Brabazon of Tara, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Brooke of Sutton Mandeville, L. Conservative Life peer Brougham and Vaux, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Browning, B. Conservative Life peer Buscombe, B. Conservative Life peer Caithness, E. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Carrington of Fulham, L. Conservative Life peer Chalker of Wallasey, B. Conservative Life peer Colwyn, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Cope of Berkeley, L. Conservative Life peer Cormack, L. Conservative Life peer Courtown, E. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Crathorne, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Crickhowell, L. Conservative Life peer De Mauley, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Deben, L. Conservative Life peer Deighton, L. Conservative Life peer Dixon-Smith, L. Conservative Life peer Dobbs, L. Conservative Life peer Eaton, B. Conservative Life peer Eccles of Moulton, B. Conservative Life peer Eccles, V. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Eden of Winton, L. Conservative Life peer Edmiston, L. Conservative Life peer Farmer, L. Conservative Life peer Faulks, L. Conservative Life peer Fink, L. Conservative Life peer Finkelstein, L. Conservative Life peer Flight, L. Conservative Life peer Fookes, B. Conservative Life peer Forsyth of Drumlean, L. Conservative Life peer Fowler, L. Conservative Life peer Framlingham, L. Conservative Life peer Freud, L. Conservative Life peer Gardiner of Kimble, L. Conservative Life peer Gardner of Parkes, B. Conservative Life peer Geddes, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Glenarthur, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Glendonbrook, L. Conservative Life peer Goodlad, L. Conservative Life peer Goschen, V. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Griffiths of Fforestfach, L. Conservative Life peer Hanham, B. Conservative Life peer Harding of Winscombe, B. Conservative Life peer Higgins, L. Conservative Life peer Hodgson of Abinger, B. Conservative Life peer Holmes of Richmond, L. Conservative Life peer Hooper, B. Conservative Life peer Horam, L. Conservative Life peer Howe of Aberavon, L. Conservative Life peer Howe, E. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Hunt of Wirral, L. Conservative Life peer Hurd of Westwell, L. Conservative Life peer Inglewood, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Jenkin of Kennington, B. Conservative Life peer King of Bridgwater, L. Conservative Life peer Kirkham, L. Conservative Life peer Knight of Collingtree, B. Conservative Life peer Lamont of Lerwick, L. Conservative Life peer Lang of Monkton, L. Conservative Life peer Lawson of Blaby, L. Conservative Life peer Leach of Fairford, L. Conservative Life peer Leigh of Hurley, L. Conservative Life peer Lexden, L. Conservative Life peer Lindsay, E. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Lingfield, L. Conservative Life peer Liverpool, E. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Lothian, M. Conservative Life peer Luke, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Lyell, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary MacGregor of Pulham Market, L. Conservative Life peer Mackay of Clashfern, L. Conservative Life peer Magan of Castletown, L. Conservative Life peer Marlesford, L. Conservative Life peer Mobarik, B. Conservative Life peer Moore of Lower Marsh, L. Conservative Life peer Morris of Bolton, B. Conservative Life peer Moynihan, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Naseby, L. Conservative Life peer Nash, L. Conservative Life peer Neville-Jones, B. Conservative Life peer Neville-Rolfe, B. Conservative Life peer Newlove, B. Conservative Life peer Noakes, B. Conservative Life peer Norton of Louth, L. Conservative Life peer Oppenheim-Barnes, B. Conservative Life peer Patten, L. Conservative Life peer Perry of Southwark, B. Conservative Life peer Popat, L. Conservative Life peer Ridley, V. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Risby, L. Conservative Life peer Sanderson of Bowden, L. Conservative Life peer Seccombe, B. Conservative Life peer Selborne, E. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Selkirk of Douglas, L. Conservative Life peer Selsdon, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Shackleton of Belgravia, B. Conservative Life peer Sharples, B. Conservative Life peer Sheikh, L. Conservative Life peer Shephard of Northwold, B. Conservative Life peer Sherbourne of Didsbury, L. Conservative Life peer Shields, B. Conservative Life peer Skelmersdale, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Spicer, L. Conservative Life peer Stedman-Scott, B. Conservative Life peer Stewartby, L. Conservative Life peer Stowell of Beeston, B. Conservative Life peer Suri, L. Conservative Life peer Taylor of Holbeach, L. Conservative Life peer Teller Trefgarne, L. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Trenchard, V. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Trimble, L. Conservative Life peer Tugendhat, L. Conservative Life peer Ullswater, V. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Vinson, L. Conservative Life peer Wakeham, L. Conservative Life peer Wasserman, L. Conservative Life peer Wei, L. Conservative Life peer Wheatcroft, B. Conservative Life peer Wilcox, B. Conservative Life peer Williams of Trafford, B. Conservative Life peer Younger of Leckie, V. Conservative Excepted Hereditary Crossbench (18) Aberdare, L. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Armstrong of Ilminster, L. Crossbench Life peer Bew, L. Crossbench Life peer Bichard, L. Crossbench Life peer Colville of Culross, V. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Curry of Kirkharle, L. Crossbench Life peer Dear, L. Crossbench Life peer Deech, B. Crossbench Life peer Greenway, L. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Laming, L. Crossbench Life peer Lane-Fox of Soho, B. Crossbench Life peer Luce, L. Crossbench Life peer Lytton, E. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Meacher, B. Crossbench Life peer O'Loan, B. Crossbench Life peer St John of Bletso, L. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Walpole, L. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Warnock, B. Crossbench Life peer Liberal Democrat (63) Addington, L. Liberal Democrat Excepted Hereditary Allan of Hallam, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Ashdown of Norton-sub-Hamdon, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Bakewell of Hardington Mandeville, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Barker, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Bonham-Carter of Yarnbury, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Brinton, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Chidgey, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Cotter, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Dholakia, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Doocey, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Dykes, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Falkner of Margravine, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Fearn, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Garden of Frognal, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer German, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Glasgow, E. Liberal Democrat Excepted Hereditary Grender, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Hamwee, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Harris of Richmond, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Humphreys, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Hussain, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Hussein-Ece, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Jolly, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Kirkwood of Kirkhope, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Kramer, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Lee of Trafford, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Linklater of Butterstone, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Loomba, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Maclennan of Rogart, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Maddock, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Manzoor, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Marks of Henley-on-Thames, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer McNally, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Miller of Chilthorne Domer, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Newby, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Teller Northover, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Paddick, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Phillips of Sudbury, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Purvis of Tweed, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Randerson, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Razzall, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Rennard, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Roberts of Llandudno, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Roper, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Scott of Needham Market, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Shipley, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Shutt of Greetland, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Smith of Clifton, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Smith of Newnham, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Stephen, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Stoneham of Droxford, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Suttie, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Taylor of Goss Moor, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Teverson, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Thomas of Gresford, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Tope, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Tyler, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Wallace of Saltaire, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Wallace of Tankerness, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Walmsley, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Willis of Knaresborough, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Wrigglesworth, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Other (3) Browne of Belmont, L. Democratic Unionist Party Life peer Empey, L. Ulster Unionist Party Life peer Rogan, L. Ulster Unionist Party Life peer Tellers for the Not Contents Bassam of Brighton, L. Labour Life peer Tunnicliffe, L. Labour Life peer Members voting Not Content Bishops (1) Coventry, Bp. Bishops Bishops Crossbench (24) Adebowale, L. Crossbench Life peer Alton of Liverpool, L. Crossbench Life peer Berkeley of Knighton, L. Crossbench Life peer Broers, L. Crossbench Life peer Clancarty, E. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Eames, L. Crossbench Life peer Elystan-Morgan, L. Crossbench Life peer Hardie, L. Crossbench Life peer Haskins, L. Crossbench Life peer Hayman, B. Crossbench Life peer Kakkar, L. Crossbench Life peer Kerr of Kinlochard, L. Crossbench Life peer Kilclooney, L. Crossbench Life peer Listowel, E. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Low of Dalston, L. Crossbench Life peer Mar, C. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Martin of Springburn, L. Crossbench Life peer Masham of Ilton, B. Crossbench Life peer Mawson, L. Crossbench Life peer May of Oxford, L. Crossbench Life peer Sandwich, E. Crossbench Excepted Hereditary Stern, B. Crossbench Life peer Sutherland of Houndwood, L. Crossbench Life peer Young of Hornsey, B. Crossbench Life peer Labour (143) Adams of Craigielea, B. Labour Life peer Adonis, L. Labour Life peer Anderson of Swansea, L. Labour Life peer Andrews, B. Labour Life peer Bach, L. Labour Life peer Bassam of Brighton, L. Labour Life peer Teller Beecham, L. Labour Life peer Berkeley, L. Labour Life peer Billingham, B. Labour Life peer Blackstone, B. Labour Life peer Blood, B. Labour Life peer Boateng, L. Labour Life peer Borrie, L. Labour Life peer Bradley, L. Labour Life peer Brennan, L. Labour Life peer Brooke of Alverthorpe, L. Labour Life peer Brookman, L. Labour Life peer Carter of Coles, L. Labour Life peer Chandos, V. Labour Life peer Christopher, L. Labour Life peer Clark of Windermere, L. Labour Life peer Clarke of Hampstead, L. Labour Life peer Cohen of Pimlico, B. Labour Life peer Collins of Highbury, L. Labour Life peer Corston, B. Labour Life peer Crawley, B. Labour Life peer Cunningham of Felling, L. Labour Life peer Davies of Coity, L. Labour Life peer Davies of Oldham, L. Labour Life peer Desai, L. Labour Life peer Donoughue, L. Labour Life peer Drake, B. Labour Life peer Dubs, L. Labour Life peer Elder, L. Labour Life peer Farrington of Ribbleton, B. Labour Life peer Faulkner of Worcester, L. Labour Life peer Foulkes of Cumnock, L. Labour Life peer Gale, B. Labour Life peer Giddens, L. Labour Life peer Golding, B. Labour Life peer Goldsmith, L. Labour Life peer Goudie, B. Labour Life peer Gould of Potternewton, B. Labour Life peer Grantchester, L. Labour Excepted Hereditary Griffiths of Burry Port, L. Labour Life peer Grocott, L. Labour Life peer Hanworth, V. Labour Excepted Hereditary Harris of Haringey, L. Labour Life peer Harrison, L. Labour Life peer Haworth, L. Labour Life peer Hayter of Kentish Town, B. Labour Life peer Healy of Primrose Hill, B. Labour Life peer Henig, B. Labour Life peer Hilton of Eggardon, B. Labour Life peer Hollick, L. Labour Life peer Hollis of Heigham, B. Labour Life peer Howarth of Newport, L. Labour Life peer Howells of St Davids, B. Labour Life peer Howie of Troon, L. Labour Life peer Hoyle, L. Labour Life peer Hughes of Woodside, L. Labour Life peer Hunt of Chesterton, L. Labour Life peer Hunt of Kings Heath, L. Labour Life peer Hutton of Furness, L. Labour Life peer Irvine of Lairg, L. Labour Life peer Jay of Paddington, B. Labour Life peer Jones, L. Labour Life peer Judd, L. Labour Life peer Kennedy of Southwark, L. Labour Life peer Kestenbaum, L. Labour Life peer King of Bow, B. Labour Life peer Kinnock of Holyhead, B. Labour Life peer Kinnock, L. Labour Life peer Kirkhill, L. Labour Life peer Knight of Weymouth, L. Labour Life peer Layard, L. Labour Life peer Lea of Crondall, L. Labour Life peer Levy, L. Labour Life peer Liddell of Coatdyke, B. Labour Life peer Lipsey, L. Labour Life peer Lister of Burtersett, B. Labour Life peer MacKenzie of Culkein, L. Labour Life peer Mallalieu, B. Labour Life peer Maxton, L. Labour Life peer McAvoy, L. Labour Life peer McDonagh, B. Labour Life peer McFall of Alcluith, L. Labour Life peer McIntosh of Hudnall, B. Labour Life peer McKenzie of Luton, L. Labour Life peer Mendelsohn, L. Labour Life peer Monks, L. Labour Life peer Morgan of Ely, B. Labour Life peer Morgan of Huyton, B. Labour Life peer Morris of Aberavon, L. Labour Life peer Morris of Handsworth, L. Labour Life peer Morris of Yardley, B. Labour Life peer Nye, B. Labour Life peer O'Neill of Clackmannan, L. Labour Life peer Parekh, L. Labour Life peer Patel of Blackburn, L. Labour Life peer Pendry, L. Labour Life peer Pitkeathley, B. Labour Life peer Plant of Highfield, L. Labour Life peer Ponsonby of Shulbrede, L. Labour Life peer Prescott, L. Labour Life peer Prosser, B. Labour Life peer Quin, B. Labour Life peer Radice, L. Labour Life peer Ramsay of Cartvale, B. Labour Life peer Rea, L. Labour Excepted Hereditary Rebuck, B. Labour Life peer Reid of Cardowan, L. Labour Life peer Rendell of Babergh, B. Labour Life peer Richard, L. Labour Life peer Robertson of Port Ellen, L. Labour Life peer Rooker, L. Labour Life peer Rosser, L. Labour Life peer Rowlands, L. Labour Life peer Royall of Blaisdon, B. Labour Life peer Sawyer, L. Labour Life peer Scotland of Asthal, B. Labour Life peer Sherlock, B. Labour Life peer Smith of Basildon, B. Labour Life peer Smith of Gilmorehill, B. Labour Life peer Snape, L. Labour Life peer Soley, L. Labour Life peer Stevenson of Balmacara, L. Labour Life peer Stone of Blackheath, L. Labour Life peer Taylor of Blackburn, L. Labour Life peer Temple-Morris, L. Labour Life peer Thornton, B. Labour Life peer Tomlinson, L. Labour Life peer Triesman, L. Labour Life peer Tunnicliffe, L. Labour Life peer Teller Turner of Camden, B. Labour Life peer Watson of Invergowrie, L. Labour Life peer Wheeler, B. Labour Life peer Whitaker, B. Labour Life peer Whitty, L. Labour Life peer Wood of Anfield, L. Labour Life peer Woolmer of Leeds, L. Labour Life peer Worthington, B. Labour Life peer Young of Norwood Green, L. Labour Life peer Liberal Democrat (2) Benjamin, B. Liberal Democrat Life peer Bradshaw, L. Liberal Democrat Life peer Other (5) Ahmed, L. Non-affiliated Life peer Maginnis of Drumglass, L. Independent Ulster Unionist Life peer Smith of Finsbury, L. Non-affiliated Life peer Stoddart of Swindon, L. Independent Labour Life peer Uddin, B. Non-affiliated Life peer